UPDATE: A Win for Workers! Pure Profit Versus Integrity; As Observed on a Local Level with Mechanics’ Strike

Screen Shot 2017-09-09 at 11.24.14 AM

The corner is quiet now and has been for a few weeks. The strikers are gone. They have been vindicated after an arbitrator found in their favor and against Napleton Cadillac of Libertyville. Congratulations to them.

The full decision can be read here. But in it, the actions of the employer were found to be unlawful, and the testimony of management was often found to be not credible. The decision uses words like “fabrication” and “piffle” in describing what Napleton management employees claim happened. The decision is worth reading. Some of the actions by Napleton appear to be especially vile — terminating a man out on disability leave, pushing out tens of thousands of dollars of strikers’ tools to be ruined in rain, and other instances of retaliation for their union activity (joining the union).

As stated in the original article below, if all employers were fair and just, unions would not be a necessity. But that is not reality. When Erwin Weil ran the dealership, he was fair and honest. The workers did not join a union because they were treated with respect and honesty. When ownership changed, so did the treatment. And that’s why unions are so powerful and so very, very necessary. They protect those who could not protect themselves alone.

This writer is a teacher at a local school district. I am also the union president. The administrators at this district are fair and honorable. While we don’t always agree, there is a true feeling of mutual respect and trust. That has not always been the case in the past. And contrary to many conservative opinions, having a union and union leadership helps the district in working with employee relations and working through problems that may arise.

In my opinion, a school district or corporation that is run fairly, competently and honorably is one where the union leadership and the management work hand-in-hand together to promote an atmosphere of cooperation and respect. If management does not respect the union, it does not respect the workers. Period.

See original article below:

For the past month, residents of Libertyville, Illinois, or anyone driving up Milwaukee Avenue in Libertyville, have been struck by an unusual sight. In front of a few car dealerships, including Napleton Cadillac, workers are on strike. The strike has been going on for a relatively long time.

When Erwin Weil owned the Cadillac dealership in this Northern Chicago suburb, he was quoted as saying, “You get what you pay for” about the ads that he appeared in. In the ad, Weil said, “I’ll make it worth your Weil.”

Erwin Weil was true to both those quotes, not only when it came to selling cars, but also when it came to his treatment of employees. He was fair and honorable and gave his workers benefits that kept them working for him for decades. Among his employees were not just certified GM mechanics, but some of the best in the nation — award winning mechanics. He provided a 401K benefit and contributed money to workers’ plans. He provided five weeks of vacation to workers who had been with him for over 20 years. He provided a 40-hour work week.

But mostly? He treated his workers with respect. They saw no need to unionize because their employer was honest and fair. They felt valued, and in turn, they worked hard for Weil Cadillac.

Isn’t that what responsible corporations do? They treat their employees fairly so that they will get the best back from those employees. Lately, it seems as if greedy corporate moguls are out to squeeze every dollar, every cent, from wherever and whomever they can. The workers are making a living wage? Cut wages! The workers have a decent retirement plan? Cut the plan! The workers have a 40-hour week? Cut hours!

So while America is losing workers who want to be in trades like the fields of auto mechanics, plumbing, and other necessary businesses, companies like the Napleton Auto Group would seem to be making those trades less attractive by cutting not only wages and benefits, but also the dignity of those doing the work.

America was built by workers. While those who own the companies and factories that make our products are in the news and live luxurious lifestyles, those who actually provide the services and make the products have been dependent on the American ideal that’s said, “Work hard and be productive and you will be rewarded.” It’s in part because workers worked hard but were not fairly rewarded that unions came into being. Unions provide power to the workers that one individual worker, or even a small group of workers, cannot have. There is, after all, strength in numbers.

That is clearly seen in the Napleton Cadillac story. For decades, Erwin Weil treated his workers fairly. But when he retired and sold the dealership to Bill and Paul Napleton, it seems that all changed. Making even more money than the dealership previously made appeared to be the order of business, and according to the striking mechanics, the respectful treatment of workers was one of the standards that didn’t make the cut with the new owners and what the mechanics believe is their “profit above all” ethic.

In what seems to be an especially despicable act, it’s alleged that the owners of the Cadillac dealership took the mechanics’ tools during the strike and left those tools outside in the rain. The striking mechanics own their own tools, and some of their tool collections are worth more than a year’s salary — as much as $100,000. When one of the larger toolboxes sank into the asphalt, it couldn’t be moved, and according to the striking mechanics, the tools inside were ruined from exposure to water during the heavy rain. There is an article as well as photos on Jalopnik about this.

The big question for readers to ponder is this: Do you believe that a worker should be treated fairly and with dignity? Encyclopedia.com says that the phrase “A labourer is worth of his hire” or in plain English, someone should be properly recompensed for effort, is originally of biblical origin.

You be the judge of the mechanics you want working on your car — the scabs who crossed the picket line and who (according to the striking mechanics) may or may not be GM certified, or the truly experienced mechanics who are on strike for a fair contract.

Note: The general manager of the Libertyville Napleton Cadillac, Dominic Florio, was contacted and offered the chance to comment on the article before publication. He refused the offer and said, “No comment.”

4 thoughts on “UPDATE: A Win for Workers! Pure Profit Versus Integrity; As Observed on a Local Level with Mechanics’ Strike

  1. A just issue to call out. My dad would definitely have something to say about this too; he’s always speaking out about the injustice of big corporations, and noting how much things have changed. There used to be the idea that “When dad gets too old to provide for the family, the company will provide for him!” but that mentality no longer exists within corporations. There’s too much of a consumerist attitude…it’s sad!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. in the age of having a businessman as President of a country (ridiculous in and of itself), only the business owner reaps the benefits. exceptions are few and far between. With his new slate of Judicial appointees, the worker will have fewer and fewer chances to earn a living wage.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I’m very happy the strikers have their jobs back and they will get their back pay. I hope NAPLETON has to replace the ruined tools as well. I will make it a point NEVER to buy car from them. I hope these greedy people are forced out of business and that someone who.has some character replaces them

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s